Over the past few weeks I’ve become increasingly concerned about Facebook. I even considered deleting my account (idea I haven’t really discarded), but the amount of people I’m going to lose contact with is making me hesitate.
So, why the concern? I’m glad you asked. You can get a rough idea by reading these articles:
- Facebook’s Eroding Privacy Policy: A Timeline
- Facebook Further Reduces Your Control Over Personal Information
- Six Things You Need to Know About Facebook Connections
- Who Knows Who Your Facebook Friends Are?
- The Evolution of Privacy on Facebook (infographic)
After reading all that, for me it’s pretty clear that Facebook doesn’t give a flying fuck about your privacy. Actually, even Zuckerberg presumably said so. That is for me the big issue: the exact problems we might have now, the current workarounds, the fact that you now have this or that option to counter some of the automatic changes by Facebook… is all irrelevant. To elaborate a bit:
- Facebook started as a much more “private” space in which you only shared information with your friends. This has radically changed, and I somehow find it disrespectful toward their users. We’re not talking about evolution here, but of pretty big “philosophical” changes. This is not what I signed up for.
- It has happened several times that Facebook has changed your privacy settings on updates. Some of those changes can’t even be countered, or it’s fairly hard to do so. That pisses me off.
- The “Facebook messing with your privacy settings” will no doubt happen again. So now, instead of using/enjoying the service, I have to fight against it.
So the current situation is that I know that Facebook can, at any moment, change something I don’t want it to, and I’ll have to read a bunch of articles to understand the threat and counter it. I don’t want to review my privacy settings from time to time “just in case”. I don’t want to wonder if my data is available to more people I’d like it to. I don’t see the point in using a service that is designed to do the opposite of what I want. And that makes me wonder why do I bother at all. Or if I want to support a company or service that behaves like that.

Posts
Maybe there is a privacy expectancy problem: people think is safe to post private contents on the Internet. Well, we knew *it is not*. We can blame Facebook default settings, rightly so. But the main source of concern should be your direct contacts, who can resend and repost anything they can see, whether you want it or not. Google CEO received much criticism because he said “there is no such thing as privacy in the Internet”.
If you want to control your contents, setup your own server. Of course, that’s not an option for the 99,9% of Facebook users.
May 10, 2010 @ 6:59 pm
It’s been a while since I am considering it too… but after reading your (so interesting btw) article and the declarations of the facebook CEO where he said that “privacy is overrated”(http://www.wired.com/epicenter/2010/04/report-facebook-ceo-mark-zuckerberg-doesnt-believe-in-privacy/)… makes me think that the best option would be putting just _the_minimum_information_ about us available… the bad news is… and what about our picture where we are tagged? :S
rvr, I think that the point is the “italic” font-style that Esteban shows us at point 1 (This is not what I signed up for). Maybe there is no such a thing as privacy… but we have the right to have it, even more when we accept (nor sign) some conditions they can change anytime. Who knows what would happen if these services weren’t free of charge… would we have the right of privacy then?
Deleting it, it’s not an option (yet) due to the reasons you already explain here (so many contacts to lose), maybe it’s time to a parallel opensource project don’t you think? ;-) -joking-
May 10, 2010 @ 8:39 pm
rvr: Yeah, I have to admit that “Internet privacy” is dangerously close to being an oxymoron :-) Still, Facebook seems to be the other extreme… after attracting a lot of users with a much more “private” service. Also, right now it’s very hard, not to say impossible, to be both “social” while using your own servers. I wonder if someone will work in some solution using Opera Unite :-D
Tena: thanks :-) I’ve also done that for now: I’ve removed most of my data, I have reviewed (again) the privacy settings to tighten them a bit more, and I have removed a bunch of people I didn’t have that much contact with in the first place. But I can’t stop thinking “what will Facebook change the next time, and when?”, and I’d feel more comfortable if I had a good alternative.
May 11, 2010 @ 10:18 pm